THE VFA PIONEER HISTORIES PROJECT
Nan Aron
“I was part of an era where women were speaking out and speaking up.”
Interviewed by Judy Waxman, January 2022
JW: Please give us your full name and also, when and where you were born.
NA: Full name is Nan Aron, only seven letters. Born in New York City at Flower-Fifth Avenue Hospital, 1948.
JW: Tell us a little about your life before you became a lawyer, your childhood. What led you in the direction that you ultimately went?
NA: I was born into a family with many strong women. My family came over to the United States during the Great Migration, in the 1880’s. My mother’s father was one of 13 brothers and sisters. My grandmother was one of six. My grandfather on my father’s side was a Republican state senator in Pennsylvania. My aunts and uncles on my mother’s side had the greatest influence on me because of their drive, their occupations, and their commitment to social justice.
Many of my aunts were social workers or teachers. Many were engaged politically in the world around them. Some were members of the Communist Party. I can recall they told me stories of raising money during the Spanish Civil War. They were outspoken. One aunt married a publisher of the Amsterdam News in New York City, and she went on to become very involved in the publishing world. They were active in the civil rights movement and one went on to teach school in the 1960’s in Mississippi.
In large part, because of the immigrant struggle and the ambition of immigrants who came to New York during the late 1800’s, they needed to earn a living. They needed to find housing. They needed to make their way to a place where they could take care of their children. But taking care of the world and taking care of the country were also priorities – and they instilled in me a passion for social justice.
During high school, I was a counselor at a camp run by the Masons. In 1965, this camp brought together young girls from the inner city of New York. Our purpose was to give them the best summer they could possibly have. That certainly introduced and exposed me to a world where young girls, particularly those from impoverished backgrounds, were delightful, inquisitive, but also needed a leg up, mentors to help them see and imagine what their future could be.
JW: Was it an interracial group?
NA: Interestingly, the camp was run by Jewish Masons in Tallman, New York, which is located next to Spring Valley. Almost all the girls were black or Latino, mostly from the Bronx. The next summer, I was a counselor for young girls in Yonkers, New York. In those days, Yonkers had pockets of impoverished families.
JW: When did you become aware of the “second wave women’s movement?”
NA: I grew up in an exciting time to be a woman. I graduated high school in ’66, just at the moment when the women’s movement was gathering steam. It was the beginning of a new era during which women were speaking out and speaking up and beginning to stand up for their rights. I feel so lucky and fortunate to have been able to launch my career at that moment.
During my early years, after high school, I was concerned with working with women who were overlooked. In 1968 during college, I got a job at the Vera Institute of Justice in New York, and went to work for the Manhattan Court Employment Project, which engaged young men in a program that enabled misdemeanants to participate in a job training program for 3-6 months. If successful, their sentences would be dismissed and they could avoid being sentenced.
Well, once I realized that women were not included in that court employment program, I created a project which had me speaking to prostitutes and streetwalkers in New York. They comprised the majority of the women who were arrested for crimes. My goal was to encourage them to participate in the Court Employment Project. The work resulted in the first-time participation of women in this project.
It wasn’t entirely a success, because those employed as prostitutes earned much more turning tricks in one night than they could in a regular job doing secretarial or other assistance work. But in any event, it certainly opened my eyes to the plight of women.
JW: You did go to law school after college, right?
NA: I went to Oberlin College and I persuaded my dean to allow me to spend my last year at Oberlin working in an urban fellowship program in Cleveland. I spent the year in a women’s prison helping the prisoners obtain the services they needed, visits with their children, health care, and classes. I represented women in courts filing motions to mitigate their sentences, spoke with probation officers on their behalf and organized classes.
I was involved at Oberlin in many social justice endeavors, primarily civil rights and protests against the war in Vietnam. Oberlin was a leader among colleges and universities in organizing protests against the war. I ran and was elected to the Student Senate for several years in a row, making social justice concerns a centerpiece of my campaigns. From Oberlin, I went to Case Western Reserve Law School in Cleveland, where I found the Women and Law Program.
During law school, we went to Columbus, Ohio several times, to lobby for repeal of the state’s abortion law that was incredibly restrictive. During law school, I also worked at Cambridge and Somerville Legal Services in 1972 and represented women in divorce, separation, and child custody proceedings.
It became clear to me that many people at the time considered custody battles, separation, divorces, to be social work. Representing women in divorce and separation cases made me realize how little power they had in relationships, and how little information about finances is imparted to them. Some of the decisions that were made about women affected not just their social standing and ability to raise a family and be in a family, but in some instances affected their lifelong careers and aspirations.
JW: Right. But I can see that people thought of that as women’s law, soft, family stuff?
NA: Right, exactly.
JW: Then you moved to DC?
NA: Moved to DC in ’73. Seems so long ago. I got a job at the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, and litigated cases involving race and sex discrimination. I represented large class actions of women, black and latino employees, and others. I sued the American Greeting Cards Company in Cleveland, Ohio for not promoting women to supervisory jobs; brought a nationwide class action against Hewlett-Packard, on behalf of women who were not being promoted to higher paying jobs at the same rate men were.
JW: Were you involved in any women’s organizations?
NA: Yes. In 1973, I joined the Women’s Legal Defense Fund. It’s now called the National Partnership for Women & Families. I immediately became active in the Fund, attending nightly meetings and participated on the screening committee which decided which cases for the Fund to bring. I chaired the employment counseling committee, and as part of my responsibilities, I wrote a manual for women in the District of Columbia on how to bring an employment discrimination case. I don’t know that I’ve got that manual. I hope maybe the Fund still has it.
I also was elected president of the Fund for several years. My day job and my night jobs were very much in sync. I was involved in national litigation at the EEOC, and local work with the Fund. I met lawyers throughout the district, Maryland, and Virginia who were also bringing lawsuits against major institutions in the area for sex discrimination.
In fact, I almost brought a case on my own behalf, but it settled quickly. When my husband and I moved to DC, I went to open a bank account in my own name. I was informed by the bank that I needed to open the account in my husband’s name. In my case, it was humorous because my last name and my husband’s are almost identical.
I quickly left the bank and called Judith Lichtman, the head of the Women’s Legal Defense Fund. I wrote a letter to the bank on behalf of the Women’s Legal Defense Fund indicating that the policy was discriminatory and that I would challenge it in court. I got word from the bank that they changed their policy.
These were very heady early days of the movement. The EEOC had hundreds of women lawyers, very committed to pursuing cases on behalf of women’s rights. In those days, before the Republicans took over in 1980, the Commission actively was aggressively pursuing cases filed by women across the country and for women.
JW: Back to the Women’s Legal Defense Fund, you said you were on the screening committee on employment issues?
NA: The screening committee received requests from women from DC, Maryland, Virginia, asking for help on a range of issues, some related to child custody and divorce, some related to employment, and others. There were maybe five or six lawyers on the committee who would screen the cases. If we agreed that a case was worthwhile to pursue, we would then call upon any number of women who were on a roster of volunteer attorneys, and send cases to them to handle.
Years later, I recall reading the complaint that was filed on behalf of a nationwide group of women against Walmart in a sex discrimination case. I was surprised. I was struck by how the allegations in the Walmart case that were filed decades after the complaints we filed in the 1970’s resembled them.
From the EEOC, I went, in 1976, to the National Prison Project, where I litigated cases on behalf of prisoners around the country challenging conditions of confinement. I do recall one case in particular. I ended up taking a case on behalf of a group of women prisoners at the prison at Bedford Hills, New York.
Bedford Hills has housed women prisoners for decades. In fact, some very well known women prisoners, including Jean Harris, were sent there. I represented a group of women there who were punished not by physical but rather emotional abuse. These women were given heavy doses on a daily basis of psychotropic drugs to keep their behavior in line with what the prison deemed acceptable.
They were also subjects in a behavior modification program, again, that relied on the giving of drugs. I remember winning that case on behalf of women prisoners before an enlightened district court judge named Marvin Frankel in New York City. He awarded the women monetary damages based on forced medication.
I was subject to, as many of us were, sex discrimination in my professional life. My story resembles that of Lilly Ledbetter, who took her case to the Supreme Court.
At the ACLU’s Prison Project, where I worked for three years, I was informed by a co-worker that I was being paid less than the lawyer in the group. We both had worked at the prison project the same amount of time. We both graduated law school at the same time. We both at that time had two children. We both had litigated cases. I discovered by accident that he was being paid more than I was.
After that discovery, I decided to speak to the boss, Al Bronstein, and ask for a raise. I approached the director the next day. I thought strategically said, “I’m wondering if you might consider paying me what you’re paying the other lawyer,” and laid out what the similarities were. The response I got from the director was, “Well, I cannot pay you what I pay your colleague. He’s the head of a family, you’re not.”
I remember saying, “You can’t say that. You just can’t say that.” And I will just say parenthetically, the same statement was made decades later by an employer in that Walmart case. I then said to Al, “Think about it. Take 24 hours. I’m going to come back.” I came back in 24 hours. He remained adamant that he would not give me a raise. I then declared that I would appeal the decision to the head of the ACLU, Ira Glasser.
I called Ira, recounted the story and the facts, and his response was, “Well, Nan, if I make you whole and pay you on an equal basis, I’ll be opening Pandora’s box.” I said to him, “Well, I think that’s the point. If I’m being treated this way, I think probably other women at the ACLU are as well.” He said, “I can’t make the change.”
I was unwilling to stop there. I called the human resources director, who had just been appointed at the ACLU. He and I agreed that we would conduct a survey of women working at the ACLU. We found that women were not getting paid on an equal basis to men. He presented the survey to the board, and it came up with a schedule based on objective criteria, which is used today. Progressive nonprofits, in some respects, were no different from others who engaged in gender discrimination.
But I knew, as so many women plaintiffs come to know, whether they win or lose their cases, that bringing litigation on your own behalf or speaking up on your own behalf, is not easy. Even if one gets the redress they seek, you sometimes need to make a change in your life or in your career because you’ve left behind hard feelings with peers and with supervisors and directors. As a result of that experience, I decided to go off on my own, run my own organization, and I founded Alliance for Justice several months after leaving the National Prison Project.
JW: The Prison Project was part of the ACLU, right?
NA: That’s correct.
JW: You were head of the Alliance until very recently. Tell us a little bit about how women’s issues came up, and it may explain the purpose of the Alliance for Justice.
NA: Alliance for Justice is an association of over 130 organizations, and its programs are twofold. The Judicial Selection Project was created in 1984, and coincided with Ronald Reagan’s run for a second term for presidency. During his campaign, he announced that he would select federal judges who met three criteria: support for prayer in school; opposition to affirmative action; and opposition to abortion.
We were committed to helping Senate Democrats understand how important judicial nominations were to the nation. Our project collected research on each judicial nominee sent to the Senate by the Republican White House, and sent the research to the press, the Senate, academics, and organizations around the country, including women’s groups.
Many of the Reagan nominees in the 1980’s were men who had records of hostility toward women and women’s rights. We began to announce opposition to many of these candidates, issuing reports, and organizing coalitions to speak out.
We also found that many of the nominees in the 1980’s and early ’90s were men who belonged to social clubs that excluded women, blacks, latinos, and Jews. We publicized information about these exclusionary clubs and why they were so harmful. We worked with democrats on the Senate Judiciary Committee to develop guidelines that prohibited membership in discriminatory clubs.
In some instances, we opposed women candidates who had dreadful records on sex discrimination. I can think of one notable judge, Edith Jones, who went to the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, whom I’m pleased to say we stopped from going to the Supreme Court. Amy Coney Barrett is a more recent nominee whose record revealed a hostility to women’s rights and abortion. We actively opposed her nomination.
However, during times when Democrats were in office, we worked with women’s groups around the country to recruit women candidates for judgeships, starting with Jimmy Carter in the late 1970’s, who, interestingly, probably was one of the most committed Presidents in modern history, favoring diversity on the bench, more so than Clinton or Obama.
We now see during the Biden administration the appointment of some stellar women to the federal bench. Months before Biden was elected, Alliance for Justice collected names and developed a slate of candidates, many of whom were women, who were appointed by his administration.
JW: Can you give a synopsis about your involvement with Anita Hill in the Thomas hearing?
NA: Shortly after I left the EEOC, Clarence Thomas came in as chair. He was a Reagan appointee and very disinclined to bring sex discrimination (or any discrimination cases) on behalf of the Commission. He was well known to us as a very conservative lawyer. He underwent several congressional hearings that called into question his commitment to civil rights. After the EEOC, he was appointed to the DC Circuit where he served for 16 months. We knew, at that point, that he was probably on his way to the Supreme Court.
Alliance for Justice opposed his appointment to the DC Circuit. We prepared a report based on his work at the Department of Education and the EEOC to cease enforcement of the civil rights laws. When he was nominated for the Supreme Court by George Bush, we immediately announced our opposition then, again, and issued an extensive report.
We learned quite by accident that a woman who had worked for him had been subjected to sexual harassment. While we took care not to contact her, we did some research and came up with her name. We contacted the Senate Judiciary Committee, asked the committee to investigate. We had no idea whether the allegations of sexual harassment were real, but thought it important, particularly given Thomas led two civil rights agencies, to ask the committee to look into Anita Hill’s allegations.
The committee, as people might remember, was disinclined to conduct an investigation. Chairman Biden also kept hidden the allegations from the other members of the Committee. We learned later he had agreed to help confirm Thomas. In fact, he held a committee vote in the Committee on the nomination while knowing and hiding the Anita Hill allegations. Two reporters, Nina Totenberg at NPR and Tim Phips at Newsday publicized the charges.
The second set of hearings on Thomas’ nomination were explosive. They took place over a holiday weekend. Hundreds of thousands of Americans were glued to their TVs, learning, many for the first time, about sexual harassment and how damaging it is. When those hearings began, polls were taken. At the beginning of the hearings, most Americans believed Clarence Thomas and thought that she was lying.
At the end of the hearings, another set of polls was conducted, finding that a majority of Americans believed Anita Hill. Clarence Thomas was confirmed by the smallest vote at that time, 52 to 48 in the Senate; and became, as we all know, a Supreme Court Justice, where he has almost consistently voted against civil rights. Several of the democrats who voted for him have since sounded regretful.
Following those hearings and that confirmation, Bill Clinton was elected President of the United States, and a record number of women were elected to seats in the House and the Senate. There’s no doubt that the hearings had a very powerful impact on society. I’d like to think the world has changed. Although, certainly, Kavanaugh’s confirmation hearing and the allegations of sexual assault made by Christine Blasey Ford demonstrate we still have a lot of work to do to confront sexual harassment.
JW: And Kavanaugh, obviously, as well. But it’s out there as an issue and we have work to do to make people accountable. But it is now an issue, where it really wasn’t.
NA: It helped to give rise to the MeToo movement. It put survivors of sexual harassment out front in a very important way. It advanced a critically important conversation in society.
JW: Absolutely. But let me ask you one last question. We’ve heard about how the women’s movement and activities on behalf of women affected your professional life. What would you say about your personal life?
NA: In a very direct way, my daughters, like so many of our daughters, are able to have families, raise children, and also have meaningful jobs. They know they benefitted from the struggles made by women before them, and feel comfortable speaking up.
Working in a social justice nonprofit was extremely meaningful to me, and enabled me to devote myself to issues and campaigns that I cared about. Founding and leading an organization gave me the bandwidth to learn so many skills needed to work in the sector.
However, many challenges remain. Women leaders are not often treated on an equal basis with men. There’s much to be said here.
Thank you so much for the opportunity to speak with you.